Skip to main content

CrazyCris's Thoughts on Sharon Kay Penman's Devil's Brood. A Guest Post

Today I am very happy to welcome the fellow admirer of Sharon Kay Penman's novels, CrazyCris, who kindly agreed to share her thoughts and impressions after reading Devil's Brood, the last part of Ms. Penman's Angevin trilogy. You are in for a... crazy ride!

With a title like that you might expect a fantastical tale of some demon spawn, but then you wouldn’t be reading about it here at the Young King’s court, now would you? Nope. This is a much more terre à terre tale. That of quarrelsome children and stubborn parents, but on a much grander scale than that which we’re used to today, for these children’s quarrels played out across half of France in bloody fields of battle, mighty sieges and include epic tales of betrayal (but also touching scenes of loyalty amongst some of their retainers). Betrayal of each other, betrayal of their oaths, betrayal of their father… It’s almost enough to make you believe the family legend that they were descendants of the Devil via his "demonic" daughter Mélusine...


Henry, Richard, Geoffrey and John. Three crowned Kings (although one never got to reign) and a Duke. “The Devil’s Brood” were the quarrelsome male offspring of Henry, Count of Anjou, Duke of Normandy and King of England, and his legendary wife Aliénor of Aquitaine (Eleanor in English, but I’ve always preferred the French version, which is after all what she would have been called in her lifetime!). Such larger than life figures, all of them. How could anyone possibly do them justice on paper? By bringing them back down to earth and looking at them all through a magnifying glass: parents, children, associates… By examining their strengths and weaknesses and most of all their motivations. By making them feel so alive that you could almost believe you know them. What could possibly drive these brothers to constantly fight against each other? Why would a once loyal wife help her sons rebel against their father? As hard as it might seem to understand it all before you start reading, watching it unfold before your eyes makes the result seem inevitable.

It’s taken me about two weeks to read, a bit longer than the previous books in the trilogy because the final third (pretty much after the Young King’s death) was just so… heavy? Not sure which word I’m looking for… Poor Hal injected quite a bit of positive energy into the story, as he did in the lives of the people around him (well, most of them. I doubt Richard would agree). After his death the family squabbles seemed even more pointless. I was like “Come on people! You’ve already lost one family member to this mess! It’s time to come together and heal your wounds! Can’t you see the only one who will benefit from this is that snake Philippe?!” But nooooo! Because Henry was pretty much incapable of understanding his sons, and they were frustrated with his empty promises and felt they couldn’t trust him to do right by them (and were bitter towards each other), they just kept at the hamster wheel of rebellions and betrayals and battles and… argh! Was there ever a family more in need of therapy?! Sheesh! I found myself wanting to slap them all silly and force them to come to terms with each other before it was too late! And that final betrayal… damn! That one definitely cannot be justified by any means. I’m sure it broke Henry’s heart just before he died…

So those are my thoughts now that I’ve just finished the book. But going through what I’ve written on Facebook I’d like to reprise a couple of things I wrote spontaneously in the middle of sleep-deprived nights when I couldn’t put the damn thing down:

“First it was Joanna and Richard in the Holy Land (note: first SKP book I read was Lionheart), then Ranulf fighting for Maude, then Harry and Eleanor in all their glory… Now it’s their marriage woes and rebellious sons keeping me up at night!!! Will someone please tell these blasted Angevins to let me get some sleep?!?!?!”

The Devil’s Brood has me in its clutches and won’t let me go, even though I know how the story plays out, it’s just so ALIVE I’m mesmerised and can’t stop reading!!!”

“The Young King is dead, and I haven’t been able to tear my eyes away from his death throes this past hour. The whole drama behind The Devil’s Brood is heart breaking! I know much of it is Henry’s fault, but I feel so bad for him right now! One betrayal after another... (…) Every time Henry commits another blunder, it’s like watching a train wreck you know is going to happen but can do nothing to stop! It’s mesmerising but oh so frustrating!”

I have to add that after reading this book I have a newfound appreciation for these tragic siblings. I was already quite familiar with Richard’s story (as the favourite son of my favourite historical figure, how could I not be?), but knew next to nothing about the others! My opinion of John remains strongly negative, but Hal seems like a jolly fellow at whose court I would have loved to hang out, and quite frankly I think Geoffrey would have made the best king of the lot had he been given the chance!


Thanks so much Kasia for inviting me to hang out in the Young King’s Court and share my thoughts! And all hail Sharon for writing such a brilliant book (and well, trilogy!) that was incredibly ALIVE!

Cristina Beans Picón a.k.a. CrazyCris in the Blogosphere.


Comments

  1. No, it is me who says big "Thank you!", Cristina!

    ReplyDelete
  2. So many books to add to 'must reads'. I haven't read any of Sharon Penman's books yet, but I did enjoy Jean Plaidy's set of books on the Angevins.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The only book of Jean PLaidy's I've read covered Edward III. I don't know the title in English as I had it in Spanish "Juramento sobre la garza" (Oath over the egret or smthg like that). One of my first historical novels, have loved the genre ever since!

      Sharon Penman's books are amongst the most "alive" that I've ever read! Her characters definitely feel like flesh and blood people, and the books are real page-turners!

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    3. My personal view is: read one Sharon Kay Penman's book (or Elizabeth Chadwick's) and you will never be satisfied with any other historical fiction author again. Ms. Penman's historical research is impressive.

      Delete
    4. Love, love, love Sharon Penmman. She spoils all other British historical fiction for me. The only other historic fiction writer who comes close to be, in my opinion, in Colleen Mc Collough's Roman histories series.


      Delete
  3. Excellent review. Cris does a great job on her movie reviews, so I knew she'd do a great job on this as well!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The History of William Marshal on the War of 1183. Part I

The anniversary of Henry the Young King's untimely passing is fast approaching and though I have discussed the surrounding events many times here, on the blog, I have never focused solely on the version introduced by one John, the author of the History of William Marshal. If we are believe to him, this is what happened in the spring of 1183 and these are the roots of the conflict that broke out between the Angevins, the conflict in which brothers stood against each other, and sons stood against father (following the translation by Nigel Bryant):

'(...) the following Lent saw conflict between the three brothers. The Young King and his brother Count Geoffrey, lord of Brittany, angrily left their father, offended and enraged that their brother, the count of Poitiers, with their father's backing, had made so bold as to wage war on the highest nobles of that land and to treat them most unjustly. They'd complained to the Young King and declared that they would sooner serve hi…

Safe Passage to Heaven

Saturday, 11 June 1183. Martel. The spring in the valley of the Dordogne lazily drifts into summer. A young man, with a sapphire ring fervently pressed to his lips, lies dying in the house of Etienne Fabri’s. He finds himself far from his family, among ‘quite barbarous people’ in Gascony, with only a few faithful companions at his side. That young man happens to be the King of England’s son and heir. Contemporary chroniclers refer to him either as Young Henry, Henry the Younger, the Young King or Henry III. He does not know that since he is destined to predecease his father, his name will vanish somewhere in a dim and distant… future, almost utterly lost to posterity. Ironically, it is Henry’s untimely passing-the best documented moment of his life-that he is mainly remembered for. Additionally, the actions surrounding his death serve as an invaluable source of information concerning the rituals performed at the twelfth-century deathbed. From his example we can learn a lot about medie…

A Few Facts About Henry the Young King

Henry the Young King was the only king of England crowned in his father’s lifetime. In this his father, Henry II followed the continental tradition. The Capetian rulers had their heirs crowned during their reign in order to avoid even a momentary interregnum and disorder. Louis VI, for instance, still active monarch, had his son, also Louis, anointed in Rheims cathedral already in 1131. It was not until 1137 that Louis began his independent rule and only upon his father’s death. The same Louis had his only son, Philip crowned in 1179, a year before he himself died. Today I would like to introduce a few facts about Henry the Young King everyone should know.
- Henry (b. 28 February 1155) was not meant to be a king. The crown was to be inherited by his elder brother, William (b.17 August 1153). Unfortunately, at the age of three, William became seriously ill and died, the only child of Henry II and Eleanor of Aquitaine, who failed to reach maturity. Upon his untimely passing, Henry, the s…