7 June 1183: 'Have Compassion upon My Most Wretched Soul!’
In
the opening months of 1183 Henry was busily occupied with
wresting control of the Duchy of Aquitaine from his younger
brother Richard. With Geoffrey, Duke of Brittany, another
younger brother, and an ardent support of Poitevan barons discontent
with Richard’s iron rule, the Young King was desperate to win a
portion of the family domains for himself. He stood in
opposition not only to Richard, who at that time was facing a
formidable French-Burgundian-Toulousain coalition backing up the
Young King, but also to his father king Henry II of
England, who hastened to Richard’s rescue. It was the second
time that Henry took up arms against his father, the King. The
underlying cause of this revolt was the same as in 1173: he did
not want to be a king only in name. In 1170 his father had him
crowned a king-associate of England, but in reality, the Young King
had no land of his own and no power to rule, the great number of his
charters from that period being only either homologues or
confirmations of his father’s charters, and his household
consisting of the officials of his father’s choosing. In fact, his
younger brothers, Richard, Duke of Aquitaine and Geoffrey, Duke
of Brittany enjoyed more real power than he, the eldest one. Thus, in
taking over Aquitaine, Richard’s maternal inheritance, the
Young King saw his chance of gaining real authority and financial
independence. With his mighty allies he might have achieved this very
goal had he not contracted bloody flux (dysentery). On
26 May, in the town of Uzerche, he suffered from - as it may seem -
the first bout of illness, but he quickly came to himself. In fact he
was well enough to pillage the
shrine of St Amadour at Rocamadour.
Rocamadour today (photo: Patrick Clenet)
Together
with the booty he carried off a sword which was said to be Durendal,
the weapon of the legendary hero, Roland. There were precious relics
in its hilt: the tooth of St Peter, the blood of St Basil, hair of St
Denis and a piece of the robe of the Blessed Virgin. As Emma Mason
points out in "The Hero's Invincible Weapon: an Aspect of
Angevin Propaganda”: 'If the Young King accepted that his
booty was indeed the Durendal of Roland, then he would believe
himself to be under the protection of these powerful relics. Perhaps
perceiving himself as a hero-figure in his contest against his
father, he might prize an object which would be widely recognized as
an emotive symbol... In his looting of Rocamadour, the Young King was
perhaps seeking not only material reinforcement, but also the means
of projecting a charismatic image' (pp. 126-127). Looting itself
certainly could not have helped him, but the sword of Roland could.
Richard often employed the projection of a heroic image as a part of
his military tactics. As it turned out, however, Durendal proved to
be useless in protecting Henry against more dangerous foe, whose
severe and full-scale attack launched from within proved fatal.
Dysentery was the curse of the medieval warfare, wrecking havoc and
taking its toll in the military camps. On Tuesday, the 7th
of June, it was clear that the Young King was not going to
survive. One can only try to imagine what scenes accompanied breaking
of this sad news - Henry's household knights must have been utterly
distraught. I completely disagree with the author Sharon
Kay Penman, who in the King's Ransom - the novel about Henry's
brother Richard I Couer de Lion - says that neither Henry
II nor Henry the Young King inspired such loyalty from their men
as Richard did. It is enough to read about their last hours to see
they had a few absolutely loyal men with them.
Maison
Fabri, Martel, where Henry the Young King spent the last days of his
life.
But
back to the little town of Martel, Limousin, deep in the south
of Aquitaine, where Henry just realised it was time to
say "Farewell" and prepare himself to face the
Maker. Taking into account the working of the
twelfth-century mind, he must have believed himself a condemned
criminal, and his illness a divine punishment, especially if he
was the sole victim of the malady (I was unable to determine if there
were others in Henry's household and troops who succumbed to it as
well at the time). For this reason he sought rescue in all possible
ways of repentance. After all, he had not only betrayed his
father, but also pillaged the most sacred shrines in
Western France (St Martial near Limoges, Grandmont and St Amadour at
Rocamadour). To make amends and to show how he regretted, he
prostrated himself naked on the floor, and before the crucifix
confessed his sins to Gerald, Bishop of Cahors. As death
drew near he had a hair shirt put on him and asked to be dragged out
of bed by a noose wound round his neck. ‘By this
cord,’ he was to say, ‘do I deliver myself, an unworthy,
culpable, and guilty sinner, unto you, the ministers of God,
beseeching that our Lord Jesus Christ, who remitted his sins to the
thief when confessing upon the cross, will, through your prayers, and
through his ineffable mercy, have compassion upon my most wretched
soul!’ According to his wishes, he was then placed
on a bed of ashes on the floor, with stones under his head
and his feet, ‘in the manner which St Martin prescribed
for monks’. He still had four days to live.
A
detailed account of Henry's unfortunate campaign on 11 June.
A very moving story - and vividly told, as usual. Thanks for another great post about The Forgotten King, Kasia. I look forward to the campaign post! There'll be lots of great detail for anecdotes to use in my future live-talks about Henry's mum - Eleanor. Or just for me to enjoy reading! :-)
ReplyDeleteBest, Ulrik
Thank you, Ulrik! You are very kind :-) I wish I could listen to your talk on Eleanor one day...
DeleteI have plans to make an online version of some sort, so maybe ... :-)
DeleteSounds fantastic! Please let me know when it's ready, Ulrik! I am looking forward to it :-)
DeleteAnd yet in Penman's novel, as the Young King realises he is dying, his knights and household are shown as being absolutely devastated, as they naturally would have been. Young Henry had been full of life and an example of the chivalric code with his taking part in tournaments. His followers must have been looking forward to a glittering reign - he promised so much.
ReplyDeleteI cannot understand it, Anerje. Sharon Kay Penman's portrayal of the Young King is the best and "the fullest", if I can use the word :-) One can learn Henry's bio from her Devil's Brood. And yet what she says about Henry in her blog posts stands in stark contrast to her Hal from the novel. She doesn't hold him in high esteem. I wonder how she could show him so much uderstanding only to direct such harsh criticism at him later.
DeleteSorry I am late in seeing this. Wonderful post. xx Shared on fb. Hope you are doing well. x
ReplyDeleteThank you for your kind words and sharing, dear Marsha :-) As always much appreciated. I'm fine, thank you. I promise to e-mail you ASAP.
DeleteKasia, thank you for this well-written post, reminding us again not only of the young King's tragedy, but also the mindset at the time. We can't imagine today the horrific anguish of believing an eternity of Hell awaited you. Well, I'll qualify that. We were plagued with that horror as kids growing up in a very medieval religious system, Catholic of course. And that wasn't very long ago! Oh what freedom when we renounced the whole kit & kaboodle! I have great sympathy for all that psychological torture in the MA.
ReplyDeleteCiao, Joan
Thank you, Joan. I am happy you enjoyed it. Heaven and hell, salvation and damnation were very real at the time, weren't they? It must have been - as you put it - psychological torture plus quite useful weapon to manipulate poor sinners.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteGreat blog post!!! its worth to read this. I found out some more great stuff to read.
ReplyDeleteweb design
Thanks, bar kerark :-)
ReplyDeleteUnfortunately, I was forced to delete Anderson Joey's comment. It had nothing to do with the Young King - just advertising. I think I will have not other choice but to improve this blog's security system :-)
ReplyDelete