Skip to main content

Short Notes On Work In Progress...

As you may know I am currently working on a post about Henry and his younger brother Richard who was to go down in history as Couer de Lion. When researching and re-reading, I have come across this - as I would call it - key quote concerning Henry II and the way he treated his eldest son and heir. I am sharing it with you now, but will make proper use of it and discuss it at length when writing about Henry, his younger brother John and who was the real Lackland in the family.

In his biography of Richard, John Gillingham gives a vivid description of Henry senior, quoting and analyzing works of Henry's courtiers, Walter Map among them. It was Walter who was to report that when ruling and dealing with his subjects his liege lord usually employed methods adopted from his mother, Empress Matilda. According to Walter "he seems to have dealt with those who came to him with requests by saying that he would do something for them, and then repeating this promise whenever he had to, postponing action for as long as possible." (Gillingham, p. 31)

"He should keep aspirants waiting in hope," the Empress was to instruct him, "deliberately spinning out their affairs, for an unruly hawk, if meat is held out to it  and then snatched away and hid, will become keener and more inclined to be attentive and obedient." (Gillingham, p. 31). If only the Empress - if she ever had said so - could have forseen that her firstborn would employ this very method when dealing with his own sons, who, in turn would prove to be as much as the unruly hawks as he must have been when being their age, the eldest surviving saying on one occasion that he was no bird to be mewed up [The History of William Marshal]. He said that when spending most of 1175 on English soil after his failed Great Revolt of 1173-74, which he had been pushed to stir up because of such repeated requests and postponed actions, however, in his case the hawk would become neither keener nor more obedient.


  1. Henry must have been hugely influenced by his mother the Empress - I have tremendous respect for her. If she did offer that advice, I'm sure she didn't foresee the effect on his own sons.

    1. Yes, it would be hard not to admire her, despite the fact that she showed poor judgement of political situation sometimes, in which she was no better than her cousin and greatest opponent King Stephen. But she was the real warrior lady in the world dominated by men, and she showed great courage and determination, winning the war in the end :)

  2. Looking forward to your new blog post. :)

  3. Me too! Henry II's relationship with his sons is a fascinating subject indeed.

  4. Thank you, Ladies :-) I hope to finish the post I am working on, publish it, then host my friend Ulrik again with the second part of his Eleanor/the Young King series and then post about Henry the Lackland ;-)

  5. Henry seems to have forgotten that Mathilda lost more than one supporter by her politics of empty promises. At some point vassals will look to someone else who may actually stick to his word. ;-)

    1. Good point, Gabriele. Henry II was probably a "control freak" and giving away power is very hard for type A personnalities.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A Few Facts About Henry the Young King

Henry the Young King was the only king of England crowned in his father’s lifetime. In this his father, Henry II followed the continental tradition. The Capetian rulers had their heirs crowned during their reign in order to avoid even a momentary interregnum and disorder. Louis VI, for instance, still active monarch, had his son, also Louis, anointed in Rheims cathedral already in 1131. It was not until 1137 that Louis began his independent rule and only upon his father’s death. The same Louis had his only son, Philip crowned in 1179, a year before he himself died. Today I would like to introduce a few facts about Henry the Young King everyone should know.
- Henry (b. 28 February 1155) was not meant to be a king. The crown was to be inherited by his elder brother, William (b.17 August 1153). Unfortunately, at the age of three, William became seriously ill and died, the only child of Henry II and Eleanor of Aquitaine, who failed to reach maturity. Upon his untimely passing, Henry, the s…

The History of William Marshal on the War of 1183. Part I

The anniversary of Henry the Young King's untimely passing is fast approaching and though I have discussed the surrounding events many times here, on the blog, I have never focused solely on the version introduced by one John, the author of the History of William Marshal. If we are believe to him, this is what happened in the spring of 1183 and these are the roots of the conflict that broke out between the Angevins, the conflict in which brothers stood against each other, and sons stood against father (following the translation by Nigel Bryant):

'(...) the following Lent saw conflict between the three brothers. The Young King and his brother Count Geoffrey, lord of Brittany, angrily left their father, offended and enraged that their brother, the count of Poitiers, with their father's backing, had made so bold as to wage war on the highest nobles of that land and to treat them most unjustly. They'd complained to the Young King and declared that they would sooner serve hi…

28 February 1155: In Celebration of Henry the Young King's Birthday

On the pages of his Chronicon Geoffrey, prior of Vigeois, described in meticulous detail how young Henry packed as much repentance into his deathbed as he could before he passed away.  Geoffrey left nothing unsaid. The hair shirt, bed of ashes, halter around neck, Bernard, bishop of Agen administering the last rites, and many other men of religion … all was there to ‘draw the readers attention away from the affairs of this world to those of the next’. Of course, Geoffrey, a man of religion himself, must have seen young Henry’s untimely passing as a divine punishment. But there were other voices who disagreed with that of the prior. Thomas de Agnellis, for example, in his sermon claimed that as the Young King’s sad retinue was toiling over the jolly sunbathed hills and dales of Aquitaine, it became the focus for many miracles. The rumors of the late king’s sainthood began to circulate. The monasteries pillaged by him shortly before his death- as it happened some of the most sacred shri…